How important is interacting with others in the scope of
performing work activity? According to many vocational witnesses, a limitation
to occasional interactions with others does not cause a lot of erosion.
According to the ORS (2023 and 2024) less than 40% of jobs require basic people
skills, the rest require more than basic people skills. If we accept the ORS as
authoritative, workers must have at least basic people skills in every job. SSA
policy, the basic mental demands of competitive, remunerative, unskilled work
includes responding appropriately to supervision, coworkers, and work
situations. POMS
DI 20520.010 A.3.a. The critical requirements of unskilled work
include:
f. sustain an ordinary routine without special supervision.
g. work in coordination with or proximity to others without
being (unduly) distracted by them.
j. ask simple questions or request assistance.
k. accept instructions and respond appropriately to criticism
from supervisors.
l. get along with coworkers or
peers without (unduly) distracting them or exhibiting behavioral extremes.
POMS DI 20520.010 B.3.
This is standard stuff on the tool belt of many
representatives.
What is missing from the POMS fleshing out the "such
as" list from 20 CFR § 404.1545(c)
is a temporal restriction. The regulations and the DOT define exertion by constant,
frequent, and occasional lifting, sitting, or standing. But the vocational
literature does not permit the person to occasionally play well with others.
POMS lays out the criteria, the worker either does not does not work with
others, ask of others, accept direction, or get along with others or the worker
does not. The worker is either pleasant or neutral or the worker is sometimes
irritable. How often does a coworker or supervisor have to interact negatively
with others in order to invoke progressive discipline?
Harassment, discrimination, insubordination, violence,
or threats fall into the serious misbehavior category and can result in
immediate termination. It is not occasional, it is one and done
Minor issues can invoke progressive discipline. Those steps
can include:
Coaching/counseling
Verbal warning
Written warning
Suspension/demotion
Termination
A person that can occasionally tolerate interaction with
others, as an unskilled worker, does not get to pick and choose when they will
interact with coworkers or supervisors. Work happens when work needs to happen
whether the impaired person is ready or not. The wide range of misconduct that
does not warrant immediate termination may include:
Attendance Issues
Occasional or chronic tardiness
Taking extended or unauthorized breaks
Unexcused absences or failure to notify a supervisor when
absent
Performance Issues
Producing subpar or incomplete work
Failing to meet established productivity standards or
deadlines
Conduct Issues
Minor dress code violations.
Minor incidents of unprofessional language or an
inappropriate tone during discussions.
Gossiping or badmouthing colleagues.
Conducting personal business during work hours.
Unauthorized or excessive use of company equipment, such as
telephones or computers, for personal use.
A generally negative attitude or unwillingness to work
collaboratively.
Minor insubordination or a one-time
refusal to follow a non-critical instruction
We need an example. Vocational witnesses have identified
marker (DOT
209.587-034) as an occupation with a large number of jobs. The O*NET addresses
the concerns of interacting
with others.
Communicating with supervisors, peers, or
subordinates is very important.
Getting information is very important.
Face-to-face discussions with individuals
within teams is daily.
Occasional or less contact with others exists
in 4% of jobs.
Working with a group or team in not
important in 4% of jobs.
Dealing with external customers or the
public is not important in 3% of jobs.
Working without
close physical proximity exists in 11% of jobs.
The proposition that unskilled work exists for people with
limitations in dealing with coworkers and supervisors is spurious at best.
One comment is in order as a concession. If a person needs
more than seldom or occasional contact with supervisors after the initial
training period, that person needs special supervision and is unemployable in
competitive work.
Press the envelope.
Suggested Citation:
Lawrence Rohlfing, Interacting with Others -- Another Look, California Social Security Attorney (April 25, 2026) https://californiasocialsecurityattorney.blogspot.com
The author has been AV-rated since 2000 and listed in Super Lawyers since 2008.

No comments:
Post a Comment